Saturday 1 June 2013

How to make KoM into a genuine climber's competition.

Something I find frustrating and annoying in stage races is that the King of the Mountain points are - in the first couple of weeks - usually hoovered up by people in breaks. It is the first person to cross the summit who gets the points, not the person who was fastest up the hill.

Likewise the Sprint points - how many times have we seen a break of riders in shitsmall teams sail unconcernedly across the Sprint point, not even bothering about who gets the points.

Sprinting is a bit of a problem, but I have a perfectly workable suggestion as to how to make the KoM competition more realistic.

As you probably know,  each bike has a transponder (microchip) on it, so that at the finish line, the organisers can take an accurate timing of when the bike crosses the line.

It's that little square thing, usually hanging down from the back section of the frame: 



This is why, incidentally,  there is sometimes a delay in announcing the winners - if riders have had to change bikes mid-course, or have swapped with another rider, it can cause some confusion as the transponder is either missing (if it's a spare bike) or comes up with the wrong rider's name.

So here's my first suggestion: add more decoder loops at the bottom and the top of a KoM hill, then it can easily be seen who got up it fastest.

Simple, huh?

OK, it takes out the tantalising "shall we attack? Or shall we look at each other?" tactics, and reduces it to merely who can steam up the fastest - but isn't that what climbing is about? Who can do it fastest?

Mid-race Sprints are a bit trickier: my first thought was that instead of there being just one air bridge across the road, there should be two, set a certain distance apart, so that we can see who got from the front to the end of that section the fastest. The final sprint would still be a mad scramble, by the way, I'm not proposing to change that one.

I can see a few objections to the Sprint suggestion: it removes all the tactics, and that fine judgement as to when to go and when to hold back. It would require anyone not intending to compete to move to, say, the left, to avoid blocking anyone steaming up from behind. It possibly would turn the mid-race sprints from being a display of strength and skill, to merely being strength.

And it would look a bit odd, possibly, to see someone way, way off the back of the peloton suddenly surging forward, having saved their strength for the past hour or more.  And, worst of all, there would not be an obvious immediate winner, it would have to be announced once all the riders had passed that point.

I suppose those objections would also apply to my KoM plan. But I think there's validity in the suggestion.

And if anyone is thinking how easy it might be for riders to swap bikes in order to cheat - well, there are cameras everywhere these days, and I suppose it would be as easy to have the transponder in, say, the heartrate monitor,  so we are tracking the rider rather than the bike.

Simple, don't you think?

8 comments:

  1. Hi Coug!
    This is an alarming report, which I sincerely hope is NOT true:
    http://www.cyclingnews.com/news/report-becca-to-sell-worldtour-licence-to-trek-release-frank-schleck

    Time to start sending out the death ray thoughts to Becca again, I see *squints and concentrates really, REALLY hard*

    Bris. Gal

    ReplyDelete
  2. *squints and concentrates* Death - ray -- ON!

    What a lovely family friend he is. Trek, you are well shot of him. Take the licence, take what riders you have, and start again.

    We all know that Andy and Frankie have the same contract - as I remember, they literally have the same contract, one contract for the two of them - so Mr Becca might have trouble firing one and keeping the other. Mind you, all he has to do is refuse to put Frankie on any teams, so he can't ride at race level and can't accumulate any UCI points... so why does he need to fire Frankie?

    I do hope that this is just one of those early reports, that turns out later to have a grain of truth, but to not be the whole truth.

    Poor Frankie, just what he needs to get himself psyched up for a return to racing, as if it isn't bad enough having to face the press and the peloton.. and poor Andy, doing his best to come back from a serious injury and a perfectly acceptable slow return to form, having to cope with everyone and his dog saying he's past it, and now being threatened with not having Frankie beside him.

    Pff! *rolls eyes*

    Keep sending those death-ray thoughts, Schlecklanders, and let's hope this story turns out to be untrue. After all, Mr Becca is not exactly always right in what he says, is he?

    Coug
    Gritting teeth, fingers crossed, hoping for the best, as Andy wasn't in the Dauphine, which is generally considered to be a shake-down for the Tour team...

    ReplyDelete
  3. I'm joining you in sending death-ray thoughts!

    Sigh... I just really do not understand Mr Becca if this report is true. Why would he fire Frankie now? I mean, if he really wanted to do that, why didn't he do it back in February? Then he could have had a point, as Frankie was officially banned then.

    Why on earth would he keep Frankie on the team for another FOUR MONTHS, keep his pictures and profile on the team's website, his name on the bus, let Frankie train in the official teamkit etc?! (and not to mention, probably still pay him his monthly salary?) And then when his ban is almost over, to fire him...

    I really, really hope the only part of the report that turns out to be true will be the part that Becca will be off the team from next year on. That would be wonderful news!

    Inge

    ReplyDelete
  4. I got the impression that it is Trek that doesn't want him because of the verdict. If so thought-rays should be redirected.

    On the other hand DS de Mol is quite optimistic (see a.o. wort.lu).

    Barbara(q)

    ReplyDelete
  5. The way the report was written made it sound as though it was Mr Becca, about to sell the licence, who wanted Frankie fired. This could well be a mis-translation, as once he has sold the licence, he won't have any control over riders and contracts, so maybe it is Trek who want Frankie to go... but I think they will have a fight on their hands if they try, as Andy has said many times that he and Frankie are a team. And they have one contract between them.

    I suppose we will find out in due course *sigh*.

    Meanwhile in today's news, http://www.cyclingnews.com/news/demol-confident-of-radioshacks-future Mr Bruyneel is now trying to get back a loan that he made to Mr Becca last year to pay the riders' wages.. remember that? Remember Jakob complaining that he hadn't been paid?

    Apparently Mr Becca is now being sued by Mr Bruyneel for the return of that money. And I rather think Mr Becca still has an ongoing unpaid tax investigation running... he has not exactly turned out to be a financial wizard, has he? *perfectly straight face, not sniggering at all*

    Coug

    ReplyDelete
  6. Hi Coug.
    I see no-one has commented on your KOM/sprint suggestions. Is everyone too polite to disagree with you?
    I rather like the when/if to go tactics and I enjoy watching the lesser-knowns get some glory at least in the early days. I always made a point of watching for David Moncoutie, before he retired last year. He always rode at the back of the peloton, but won 4 consecutive KOMs in the Vuelta. He always knew which breakaways to go in.
    The sprint issue is a little different. I don't like the mad scrabbles, they look too dangerous to me. It was interesting to see Cavendish make sure he got any points left over from the breakaways at the sprint points in the Giro.
    On another note, I will be in your part of the world in a week or so. Hubby and I are doing a 2 week cruise around the British Isles. I'll wave and do the Schlecklander dance on the deck as we sail by!
    emjay

    ReplyDelete
  7. Ahoy, Emjay!

    *laughs* Apparently Schlecklanders are only interested in discussing affairs related to Andy! Well, I already knew this, but he hasn't done much lately so I thought I'd throw in a non-Andy post.

    Wow, sailing round the UK, what fun! I'll run up the Schlecklander flag so you can see where we are, and will of course join in with the Schlecklander dance on the deck. In fact, I'll sail out to escort you, you can be Admiral if you like, and I'll be Commadore. *sings "And I'm eeeeeezeee, Eezee like Monday morning..!" *

    Oh, and bring woolies, it's still not hot over here: although it's the longest day in a week or so, I am still having an extra duvet on my bed at nights.

    Coug

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Sounds like a plan! I quite like "admiral emjay".
      I've been following the BBC weather forecasts, no doubt need a brolly too. It's still pretty cool here as well. Haven't done hardly any gardening, frost one night last week and 3 inches of rain last weekend.

      Delete